Insurance Risk Management Solutions for Companies & Homeowners
Vintage Car Collection

Are Your Vintage Toys Valuable? 6 Things To Know

When you were young, you collected Hot Wheels, Pez dispensers, and Lionel trains. You bought all of the accessories you could find and kept them in excellent condition. But are your vintage toys worth money now – or is their only value sentimental? Let’s take a look at how you can tell an old toy from a collectible worth insuring.

  • Rarity adds value.

    Generally speaking, vintage toys that were made in small quantities often bring a higher value than those that were mass produced. That means, if you own one of the 2,000 “Peanuts” royal blue beanie baby elephants that were manufactured with a darker blue coat than originally intended, you might have something valuable on your hands. In fact, due to a manufacturer error, this is the most collectible beanie baby around – and worth about $5,000.

  • The older the better, sometimes.

    Just because you own an old toy, doesn’t necessarily make it valuable. However, older models of toys and games are often made with materials or technology that are not used today. To date an antique toy, check the patent, maker’s mark, or country of origin mark on the toy. Or, look for an embossed, stenciled, or printed patent number on the toy or box, and send it to the U.S. Patent Office; for a fee, they will give you information about the original patent application, the name of the inventor or maker, and a date range in which the toy was made.

  • Condition matters.

    In the world of antiques, mint condition means that the original toy is still in its original box with the instructions – and has never been opened. Mint condition toys are typically worth much more than those that have been opened, played with, and show wear and tear.

  • Material can make a big difference.

    Think metal, diecast Hot Wheels, made back in the 1970s, instead of the plastic versions made today. Or, the original hand-drawn, oil cloth version of Monopoly, made in 1933 (which sold at Sotheby’s in 2011 for $146,500).

  • Restorations of Toys
  • If it needs to be restored, have an expert do it.

    While normal wear and tear is generally acceptable to most toy collectors, if something needs fixing (a spring mechanism or mechanical part), you are smart to have a professional do the work. That’s because, if you ever want to sell the toy, the restorations must be done well to maintain its value.

  • Value may be in the eyes of the beholder.

    Vintage toy collecting may be one of the most fun hobbies there is – especially if you can play with them – and one of the fastest growing fields in collecting. However, not every toy you cherish may actually be of value to others. Your best bet is to collect what you enjoy – and if it becomes an investment-worthy purchase, great. If not, you’ll still be able to enjoy your collection yourself!

If you have a large collection of antique toys or a few valuable pieces, consider getting them appraised and purchasing a valuable articles insurance policy, to help protect them against damage, loss or theft. Look for a worldwide policy so your collection is protected at your home, in transit, and in storage.


Contact Tower Street Insurance to Insure Your Vintage Toys

Whether you have possessions you've saved from childhood or you've purchased items as investments, let us help you create a policy to make sure you are fully covered if items are lost, stolen or damaged. We are risk management specialist and are here to ensure you're adequately covered.

Client Advocacy

Financial Growth Icon


Experience Icon

Collective Years of Experience

Umbrella Icon

Written Policies

Retention Icon

Retention Role

Reviews from Our Satisfied Customers

I love Tower Street and receive the best service from them! They are reliable, caring, and always supportive. Can’t recommend them enough!

- Abby

Chris is a great insurance advisor. He has extensive knowledge of markets, coverages, and risk. I highly recommend him. I wish I had more business to send him.

- Larry

Hear From Customers We've Helped

How Tower Street saved Josh 500k
Hear How Tower Street Saved Josh $500k

Top Carriers We Carry on Personal & Commercial Lines:

AIG Logo
Nationwide Private Client Logo
Pure Insurance Logo
Cincinnati Logo
Berkley One Logo
Vault Logo
Safeco Logo
Travelers Logo
The Hanover Insurance Logo
CNA Logo
Texas Mutual Logo
The Hartford Logo
Progressive Logo

See the Full List of Carriers We Offer